Skip to main content

Why we need a unified mesh for Earth system model

In many of my early posts, I shared some aspects that why I decided to develop the hexagon based watershed model, HexWatershed. 
But the real motivation lies beyond watershed and I'd like to share some personal motivation why I started this project.

For decades, since human invented computers and hydrologists invented hydrologic models, we rely on computational techniques to simulate hydrologic processes. And these techniques mostly use the structured mesh/matrix to describe the real world. Nearly all of us are familiar with the so-called X-Y-Z 3D domain.

We stand on the shoulder of giants but we seldom question them. 
It is true in earlier days that most of our research activities focus on a catchment scale or plot scale. We have to admit this is important because we need to understand the fine-scale process before we can extrapolate to a larger domain.

We never look at hydrology on a global scale using a global method. Most of us are simply trying to copy the watershed scale method to a global scale without careful evaluations.

That is where the problem comes, our Earth is not a typical X-Y-Z domain, instead, it is a sphere.
Also, our hydrologic processes interact with various components (lake, river, ocean, etc.)

Can we really use the existing method directly on a global scale? Yes and No. We have already seen many cases. But they are far from what we need. 

For example, we cannot fix the land and ocean interaction:
Besides, we cannot include Greenland and Antarctic in the global simulation.

Then how can we say we can simulate global hydrology without considering these processes?

Many readers may argue that what we are dealing with is not actually a science question and I heard it many times in my talks.
Let me explain with a naive example: How can we study the Moon? In earlier days, scientists rely on the telescope to observe the surface of Moon; later on, we sent sensors to orbit Moon to have a better observation; last, we can also collect sample directly once we can land on Moon.
With the advance in space technology, what was impossible becomes possible. 

Not only what we are doing now has many flaws, but also it cannot answer many scientific questions.
There is a difference between can and cannot.

As I always said, Steve Jobs might change the way we use technology, but it is Dennis Ritchie who invented C changed the computing world. I personally think Dennis Ritchie made it possible that we can now use computers to answer whatever science questions we have that rely on computing.

Having a unified mesh enables us to solute questions that are impossible to answer. For example, how does the coastal zone respond to climate change and affects population in these areas?

Low hanging fruits are easy to fetch, but it takes way more effort to get the higher ones, which might be much better. As a Chinese proverb says: To do a good job, an artisan needs the best tools. (工欲善其事,必先利其器.)



 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Spatial datasets operations: mask raster using region of interest

Climate change related studies usually involve spatial datasets extraction from a larger domain.
In this article, I will briefly discuss some potential issues and solutions.

In the most common scenario, we need to extract a raster file using a polygon based shapefile. And I will focus as an example.

In a typical desktop application such as ArcMap or ENVI, this is usually done with a tool called clip or extract using mask or ROI.

Before any analysis can be done, it is the best practice to project all datasets into the same projection.

If you are lucky enough, you may find that the polygon you will use actually matches up with the raster grid perfectly. But it rarely happens unless you created the shapefile using "fishnet" or other approaches.

What if luck is not with you? The algorithm within these tool usually will make the best estimate of the value based on the location. The nearest re-sample, but not limited to, will be used to calculate the value. But what about the outp…

Numerical simulation: ode/pde solver and spin-up

For Earth Science model development, I inevitably have to deal with ODE and PDE equations. I also have come across some discussion related to this topic, i.e.,

https://www.researchgate.net/post/What_does_one_mean_by_Model_Spin_Up_Time

In an attempt to answer this question, as well as redefine the problem I am dealing with, I decided to organize some materials to illustrate our current state on this topic.

Models are essentially equations. In Earth Science, these equations are usually ODE or PDE. So I want to discuss this from a mathematical perspective.

Ideally, we want to solve these ODE/PDE with initial condition (IC) and boundary condition (BC) using various numerical methods.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Initial_value_problem
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boundary_value_problem

Because of the nature of geology, everything is similar to its neighbors. So we can construct a system of equations which may have multiple equation for each single grid cell. Now we have an array of equation…

Watershed Delineation On A Hexagonal Mesh Grid: Part A

One of our recent publications is "Watershed Delineation On A Hexagonal Mesh Grid" published on Environmental Modeling and Software (link).
Here I want to provide some behind the scene details of this study.

(The figures are high resolution, you might need to zoom in to view.)

First, I'd like to introduce the motivation of this work. Many of us including me have done lots of watershed/catchment hydrology modeling. For example, one of my recent publications is a three-dimensional carbon-water cycle modeling work (link), which uses lots of watershed hydrology algorithms.
In principle, watershed hydrology should be applied to large spatial domain, even global scale. But why no one is doing it?  I will use the popular USDA SWAT model as an example. Why no one is setting up a SWAT model globally? 
There are several reasons we cannot use SWAT at global scale: We cannot produce a global DEM with a desired map projection. SWAT model relies on stream network, which depends on DEM.…